In my opinion, a huge part of what
influences teachers to use technology are standards of education, and the
government organizations which determine how they teach children. It’s in the standards!
It’s in the books! We have hybrid classes, we look up our grades online, there
are a number of things that teachers are forced (for better or worse) to adopt
to stay on the cutting edge of technology. Anything from a nation-wide
education reform like No Child Left Behind, or a local event like a school receiving
a technology grant can catapult teachers into accepting new and often useful
tools. From there, it is up to the teacher to interpret how best to use the
tools. Students don’t really choose to use technology in my opinion, they just use
what the teacher and the learning standards sets in front of them. They may
have a personal piece of technology like a PC to work and submit assignments on
(like in our class!), or a communal resource that we use (like when Taehyeong
uses the projector!). The point I’m making is students don’t have personal
influences on the technology present in their classes, it’s determined by the
higher powers in the hierarchy of the education system.
I like
the ISTE standards for the most part. They don’t focus on just making students
increasingly efficient, but it seems that they really focus on broadening the perspectives
and the tools for the student’s creativity. It empowers their personalities and
interests, and avoids forcing them into narrow corridors of education
advancement (COUGH COUGH STANDARDIZED TESTING). One standard that makes me
happy is Student Standard #2 – Digital Citizen. I think that social constructs
are important when you look at online manners and etiquette. We shouldn’t
emplace some guidelines – let the court of social opinion deal with the rabble
rousers. This standard insures that happens. One thing I’m not really sold in
Teacher Standard # 2, “Design and Develop Digital Age Learning Experiences and
Assessments.” I just think we should be cautious about using technology for
technology’s sake. If a lesson or activity can use actual physical tools better
than available tech, then by all means stick to the tried and true.
I don’t
agree with the term “digital native”, purely for the fact that it sets
expectations of proficiency on the people. I think whoever made the term was
trying to make some catch-all phrase, and that’s just not how life works. When
I was born, the internet had been around for a couple years already. By the
time I grew up the first and SECOND generations of video gaming consoles were
already aging. TV’s still had tin foil on the antenna. I’d say I’m a “digital
native.” I still am not proficient with all of the mainstream tech of today,
even though I’m a native, and I know many others share my experience. I see
differences between the natives and immigrants, but largely because of how they
apply themselves, not because of when they were born. Some older teachers I
knew could use a computer better than I could, and some had to call the school
tech support because they didn’t notice a student unplugged the projector as a
prank. The impact its had on me is that I’ve realized technology is what you
make of it. You have to have a competent user to not only interface with tech,
but to know how to integrate it into the class room setting. I know I will have
differences between myself and the next generations. There will be new tech I
can’t even imagine, but I can do my best to apply myself and stay up-to-date
with the emerging devices and techniques.
Great post! I found it interesting how you do not agree with the term digital native and your reasoning. I did not think of that!
ReplyDeleteVery well said! I definitely agree with you when you say that "we should be cautious about using technology for technology's sake". I think technology can be a great addition to learning at times, but in general, physical tools are more active.
ReplyDeleteGreat post, Will! especially your quote "The point I’m making is students don’t have personal influences on the technology present in their classes, it’s determined by the higher powers in the hierarchy of the education system." This quote makes me think a lot. In addition, the 3rd paragraph is also great. It makes us think about the term digital natives with a different angle. You're always blogging great!
ReplyDelete